We have a stormy start to the forecast period with the Storm Prediction Center putting us under a slight risk for severe weather this afternoon. Behind this storm, windy conditions will prevail Friday with the pressure gradient tightening between an incoming high pressure and the departing low. This pressure gradient eases Saturday as high pressure moves more directly overhead. Decent weather continues Sunday before another storm rolls in Monday. Above normal temperatures for Thursday in the low-60s. Temperatures drop below normal in low-50s this weekend before picking up Monday into the upper-60s.
Rest of today – lighter stratiform rain in the morning hours with a warm front moving through. This will be followed up by a possible round of strong to severe thunderstorms in the afternoon hours (most likely around 1-2PM). The primary risk for severe weather comes from the potential for damaging wind gusts, with very fast winds aloft potentially mixing down to the surface. High temperatures in the low-60s. Overnight lows around 40ºF as gusty winds bring in strong cold air advection. See this detailed forecast for more info about today.
Friday – despite a high in the low-50s, strong winds around a deepening low will make it feel significantly cooler. Clouds should gradually diminish during the day. Overnight lows cool, in the upper-30s.
Saturday – winds ease as an area of high pressure moves more directly over us. High temperatures should range in the mid-50s with plenty of sun. Overnight lows will be in the mid-40s.
Sunday– clouds increasing with high temperatures in the upper-50s. Overnight lows will warm into the low-50s.
Last Thursday, we saw a round of severe thunderstorms develop and roll through the NYC area in the afternoon hours. My instructor (Steve Corfidi) and TA (Phil Lutzak) from my Penn State World Campus Weather Forecasting Certificate program noticed an noteworthy feature in satellite images of the event.
You can see that there’s an arcing, convex, wave-like feature oriented southwest-northeast that sweeps east across the Northeast in the visible satellite loop above. If you’re having trouble spotting it check out the series of annotated images below that marks the leading edge of this feature in different points along its progression.
Professor Corfidi noted that this feature seemed to line up well with an area of drier air at the mid-upper levels of the atmosphere, which he picked up in the infrared Channel 8 satellite images. For reference, I’ve superimposed the IR channel on the visible satellite channel from the same time, which is also the 3rd frame of the gallery above.
What’s more, referring back to the visible satellite loop above, it’s evident that this feature was also partially responsible for firing up strong to severe thunderstorms along the NJ/PA border that eventually tracked east over the NYC area. Storm reports from the day indicate that several of these storms produced damaging wind gusts.
It’s evident there’s some causative relationship between this wave-like feature and the eruption of afternoon thunderstorms along its leading edge, and this all raises the question: what was this phenomenon? I did some investigation of various upper air analyses from the Storm Prediction Center and found that this phenomenon correlated well with two features at the upper levels of the atmosphere.
First, we can see that there’s a swath of increased divergence noted at 300 mb (areas outlined in pink) that correlates somewhat with this area of drier mid-upper level air. The second image is perhaps even more convincingly linked to this phenomenon – showing an area of increased potential vorticity. But what does potential vorticity indicate about the atmosphere? In this case, potential vorticity indicates a lowering of the local tropopause – the boundary between the troposphere, where all our weather takes place, and the stratosphere above it. The stratosphere, relative to the troposphere is much drier, and this explains the source of the clear drier region picked up in the GOES Channel 8 infrared images.
In fact, there’s a known relationship between potential vorticity and water vapor satellite imagery:
There is a clear relation between PV (potential vorticity) and water vapour imagery. A low tropopause can be identified in the WV imagery as a dark zone. As a first approximation, the tropopause can be regarded as a layer with high relative humidity, whereas the stratosphere is very dry, with low values of relative humidity. The measured radiation temperature will increase if the tropopause lowers. This is because of the fact that the radiation, which is measured by the satellite, comes as a first approximation from the top of the moist troposphere. High radiation temperatures will result in dark areas in the WV imagery.
Potential vorticity in this case was an indicator of increased divergence at upper levels, and this helps explain why severe thunderstorms initiated on the afternoon of Aug 21, 2019, despite the lack of a strong surface boundary providing convergence. This is because divergence and vorticity aloft helps induce convergence at the surface (and may have helped generate a prefrontal trough that day). Divergence aloft is essentially removing air from the top of the column, and since the atmospheric system always attempts to maintain a balance in terms of conservation of mass, momentum, etc, this air leaving the top of the column gets replaced by air flowing in at the surface. This is inflow of air results in convergence, and enhanced lift, as this air rises to replace the air that continues to be evacuated aloft. A source of lift is always a critical ingredient to any severe thunderstorm!
Last Thursday afternoon, April 26, 2019, a line of severe thunderstorms produced potent, damaging winds, some in excess of hurricane force that caused disruptions to regional transportation networks in the DC, Baltimore, and Philadelphia areas. These storms provide an instructive example of what ingredients are required for severe thunderstorms, and how quickly everything can come together on a given day.
Synoptic Set Up (The Big Picture)
On Thursday morning, a low centered over the Great Lakes was progressing north and east. A warm front extended south and east from this low and was moving north, with a noticeable “kink” where there was colder air at higher altitudes along the Appalachians and related foothills. South of this warm front, southerly winds were helping temperatures rise well into the upper-60s and low-70s. A cold front was located a further back and was advancing across Pennsylvania, and the Virginias. This cold front would provide the focus for lift and thunderstorms later in the day, although some more isolated thunderstorms also accompanied the warm front.
Above the surface at 850 mb, evidence suggested an axis of relatively saturated air along with a low-level jet of 35-40 knots would develop, providing the moisture necessary for precipitation. Further up in the atmosphere, a negatively tilted 500 mb trough was evident upstream of the area with the Southeast PA region also appearing to be in the exit region of a 300 mb jet streak. Both of these would help enhance lift by providing divergence aloft in the atmosphere as air was removed from the column while decelerating out of the base of the 500 mb trough and 300 mb jet streak respectively.
Fig. 1: GFS forecast model initialized at 7AM Thursday, April 26, 2019 depicting an axis/tongue of moisture (narrow area of blue) along the PA/NJ border around 5PM that day. Fig. 2: 300 mb analysis for 8PM on Thursday, April 26, 2019. Note the densely packed yellow contours close to the Southeast PA area at this time, indicating strong net divergence in the exit region of a curved jet streak at this level (blue shaded areas with wind barbs showing max winds of 80 knots slowing to 65 knots in the exit region).
Furthermore, winds throughout the atmosphere were strong, and increasing from 35 knots at 850 mb to 60 knots at 300 mb. Meanwhile winds at the surface were light, at 5 knots or so at the from the south. Winds aloft were more from the southwest. So, there was an element of both speed and directional wind shear in the atmosphere this day.
A Sunny Afternoon and Instability
From above, we see that we had several ingredients were taking shape last Thursday: a couple frontal boundaries providing focused lift, moisture at 850 mb, vorticity and net divergence at 500 mb and 300 mb enhancing lift, with strong winds at these levels enhancing wind shear. We still needed one more key component to truly set off some strong to severe thunderstorms: instability. How does instability build up in the atmosphere? The answer has to do with the daytime heating and the sun. That’s why thunderstorms often pop up later in the afternoon when daytime heating is maximized.
Fig. 3: Storm Prediction Center mesoanalysis highlighting areas favorable for severe weather on the afternoon of April 26, 2019. Fig. 4: Storm Prediction Center analysis of 3-hour mixed layer CAPE (convective available potential energy, a measure of instability) change. Note that the pocket of a large increase in instability corresponds to the location of the pocket of clear skies below. Fig. 6: A marked up visible satellite image at 3:16 PM on Thursday, April 26, 2019 showing the approximate position of frontal boundaries extrapolated from the Storm Prediction Center analysis in the preceding image.
Why does daytime heating at the surface lead to destabilization of the atmosphere? This has to do with buoyancy and lapse rates. Lapse rate describes the change in temperature over a given altitude. As the sun heats the surface of the earth up, it shifts the environmental temperature line to the right on a skewT sounding as the one attached below, taken at 2PM on Thursday, April 26, 2019 at Washington Dulles International Airport (KIAD). This tends to increase instability because a warmer airmass above the surface will have greater buoyancy. A large lapse rate combined with enhanced buoyancy allows for air from the surface to rise, and keep rising forming towering cumulus clouds that can eventually build into thunderclouds. As long as a parcel rising from the surface stays warmer than the environmental temperature profile (red line), it will keep rising.
The Storm Prediction Center was well aware that the severe weather potential was maximized for areas that saw clearing skies in advance of the approaching cold front. They also picked up on tornado potential focused on the “kinked” warm front. This is due to the fact that such an orientation of a warm front leads to a situation where surface winds are locally backed, meaning they’re turning counterclockwise over time. This was also paired with a localized pressure fall of 3 mb over the two hours leading up to 3 PM on Thursday.
As was the case with the Lee County Tornado that claimed 23 lives in Alabama on March 3, 2019, these locally backed winds due to the warm front and pressure falls (leading to some isallobaric winds) served to enhance storm relative helicity and create an environment favorable for storm rotation and the possibility for tornadoes. The backing winds also served to increase wind shear and the potential for severe weather. Luckily, in this case, other environmental factors weren’t supportive for a large, strong tornado.
Last Sunday, while I was preparing my post on the snowstorm that was about to hit NYC and the Northeast, the southern side of this same storm system was starting to produce a serious severe weather event in portions of the Deep South. A large, violent, and ultimately deadly EF4 tornado hit parts of Lee County, AL during the afternoon. The tragic toll of 23 confirmed fatalities due to this tornado was more than double the total deaths due to tornadoes in all of 2018. This was also the deadliest single tornado since the EF5 tornado that hit Moore, OK on May 20, 2013. In this post, I’ll share some thoughts and observations about the meteorology behind this event, and about what made this tornado so powerful.
Storm Prediction Center’s Forecasts
One aspect of the event that impressed me was the prescient, geographically accurate, and timely Mesoscale Discussions and convective outlooks that the Storm Prediction Center issued during the course of the day. The SPC already had a handle on the risk for severe weather in parts of the Deep South as evidenced by the convective outlooks they issued Sunday morning.
Regarding the enhanced risk area that the SPC identified as possibly being affected by tornadoes:
The most favorable … space for tornadic potential … still appears to be within the enhanced-risk area, where strong deep shear, large low-level hodographs, and at least low-end surface-based buoyancy will juxtapose. Forecast soundings show rapid prefrontal destabilization …. [a]s that occurs, severe potential will steadily ramp up…. a few tornadoes also are possible. Tornado-event density, and risk of significant tornadoes, still is somewhat unclear — being strongly dependent on existence/number of preceding supercells that can develop…
SPC foresaw that the energy (instability) and spin (shear, imparted by strong winds at different levels of the atmosphere) required for strong tornadoes would have a chance to come together in the enhanced risk area. They also identified that the greatest risk would be with any supercells that could form ahead of the main line of thunderstorms that would accompany the cold front later on.
As it turned out, supercells did form ahead of the cold front – one in particular drew the attention of astute SPC forecasters, and this would end up being the supercell responsible for the tornado that hit Lee County. In follow up Mesoscale Discussions regarding the tornado watches over the enhanced risk area, SPC forecasters were remarkably accurate and timely in identifying the risks associated with this supercell and the favorable conditions it would encounter.
MCD #0145 was issued at 1PM CDT (local time), and contained the following text. The forecasters cited favorable conditions for a strong tornado to form within 30-60 minutes. Just around 2PM, about 60 minutes after this MCD was issued, the EF4 tornado hit Lee County.
A mature supercell located near Montgomery is favorably located within a region of maximized surface pressure falls (3-4mb per 2 hours) immediately east/southeast of the surface low. KMXX VAD shows 500 m2/s2 0-1km SRH when accounting for the observed Montgomery County supercell’s storm motion. Given the ample buoyancy and intense shear profile in place, it appears tornadogenesis will likely occur within the next 30-60 minutes with the possibility of a strong tornado occurring.
Why Conditions Were So Favorable for a Strong Tornado
The following analysis about the mesoscale conditions that favored strong tornadoes on this day came about from a discussion I had with Steve Corfidi, my instructor for the class I took on mesoscale forecasting (severe weather forecasting) as part of Penn State’s Undergraduate Certificate in Weather Forecasting. Steve Corfidi also used to be the Lead Forecaster at the SPC. Suffice to say, I am quite privileged to have been able to glean some insights about this storm from him. These observations are related to another MCD from SPC that day, MCD #0147.
In this MCD, the SPC highlights an area of localized surface pressure falls in dashed blue. Steve Corfidi commented this effect is related to “rise and fall pressure “waves” that move across the earth twice-daily in response to solar heating”. As the earth heats up, air warms and rises, and this generates a thermal low since there’s less air over a warmed up spot of the earth than surrounding areas. In this case, this resulted in a localized area of surface pressure falls over the area circled in dashed blue as the day progressed. In response, surface winds will have a tendency to deflect towards the center of the lowering pressure. You can see this by looking at the wind barbs in the chart above: those that are closer to the cold front are more southwesterly, but the ones closer to the blue dashed area are actually more southerly, since they are deflecting towards the north and the localized pressure falls. This is known as the isallobaric effect. This had direct impacts on the favorability of the environment for tornadoes, as Steve Corfidi helped me understand.
As winds near the localized pressure falls became more southerly in response to isallobaric effect, this actually increased the vertical wind shear values in the area of the pressure falls (green here, blue dashed area in the SPC analysis, the red 300 mb wind profile barbs are approximated from this sounding). Since vertical wind shear is measured by looking at both the difference in direction and speed of winds at different levels, a change in wind direction at the surface, all else being equal, will result in higher wind shear. Relative to other areas in the warm sector of this storm, this produced an even higher value of storm relative helicity (SRH, as alluded to in MCD #0145) as well as the aforementioned vertical wind shear. I don’t have space to elaborate on why SRH and vertical wind shear are important for tornadoes, I will say that it has to do with enhancing storm rotation, and tornadoes are intense, vertical circulations of rotating air.
One other observation worth mentioning is that the “geometry” of the warm sector maximized the amount of time the supercell could spend in an extremely favorable environment. If you look at the large blue arrow in my illustrated diagram, check out how the approximate mean storm motion was largely parallel to the orientation of the warm front and axis of the maximized surface pressure falls. That meant that as the tornado formed, it was able to keep moving through a favorable environment for much longer than if the storm motion had been more northeasterly, or say southeasterly.
Severe thunderstorms could impact the area later today ahead of an approaching cold front. Following the passage of this cold front, conditions will begin to improve, setting us up for a weekend with pleasant, cooler, classic autumn weather.
Rest of today – Storm Prediction Center in Norman, OK has placed parts of the NYC Tri-State (the city, north and west) under a slight risk of severe weather today. Warm, moist air (read: unstable, theta-e rich) is in place with the area in the warm sector of an advancing low pressure center located in Ontario/Quebec. Some rain/thunderstorm activity could take place along a weak warm front this morning. The main focus of activity will occur later today with a cold front approaching from the west.
This cold front will be accompanied by a streak of strong upper level winds (40-50 knots), which will be capable of providing the magnitude of vertical wind shear necessary for some strong to severe thunderstorms to organize. Given the direction of the winds at upper levels being largely parallel to the advancing frontal boundary, expect that the primary storm format will be a QLCS (quasi-lineary convective system) – a line or broken line of storms. High Resolution Rapid Refresh models depict the bulk of storm activity approaching the city around 8PM this evening. Given this storm format and synoptic set up, the most likely severe threat will be damaging wind gusts. Heavy rain could trigger flash flooding as well, since the ground is still quite saturated from yesterday’s rain.
The biggest limiting factor to storm strength today will be overcast skies limiting daytime destabilization from solar heating. As is often the case, I would expect the storms to be weakening somewhat as they approach a more stable marine air layer near NYC. Overall, expect a cloudy day with high temperatures in the low-80s and a muggy feel.
Thursday – the cold front that brings us this possibly severe today will slow down as it pushes south of us, such that it remains close enough that a weak disturbance moving along it could bring us some additional showers late in the day. Skies will be partly sunny with much cooler high temperatures in the upper-60s.
Friday – easterly onshore flow on the back side of this cold front forecast to be to our south will keep skies cloudy with high temperatures around 70°F – chance for showers lingers.
Saturday – high pressure finally starts to take control of sensible weather and should produce a mostly sunny day with crisp conditions and high temperatures in the low-70s.
A wet start to the weekend will then give way to much warmer weather. We’ll get a break from the rain Sunday and Monday before the next shot for rain. Of note, a possible tornado may have impacted parts of northern Queens last night.
Rest of today – increasing chances for showers and thunderstorms especially in the early afternoon. Otherwise, mostly cloudy with high temperatures in the mid-80s.
Saturday – more widespread showers and thunderstorms in the morning, with some concern for flash flooding. The set up also could produce some isolated severe weather as a weak impulse of energy travels up the upper trough that’s been locked in over the Eastern US this week. Improving conditions later with highs in the mid-80s.
Sunday – the upper trough that’s been causing this week’s wet weather finally exits east. High pressure begins to build south of us, bringing warmer temperatures with highs in the low-90s and lots of sun.
Monday – more of the same as Sunday, sunny, hot and humid with highs in the low-90s.
Possible Tornado in Northern Queens Last Night
At 10:18 last night, residents in northern Queens, the eastern Bronx and northern Nassau received alerts from our local National Weather Service forecast office of a tornado warning. The damage was evident this morning, with many downed trees in College Point. A team from the NWS is assessing the damage to determine whether what hit this area last night was really a tornado, or if it was some other non-tornadic wind phenomena.
I was in a neighborhood that received this warning, but at first, I almost thought it was in error because there were no signs outside of anything awry, no thunder, no rain. However, a quick look at the base radial velocity imagery on the JFK high-definition terminal Doppler radar was revealing – there certainly was a storm with very strong rotation, hence why the warning notes “radar indicated tornado”. In the annotated base radial velocity image below, the white circle indicates a tight mesocyclonic circulation.
Without going too much into technical detail, the greens indicate inbound velocities relative to the radar station (air was flowing towards the radar), while oranges and reds indicate outbound velocities (where air was flowing away from the radar). When forecasters see a “velocity couplet” like this where inbound and outbound velocities are close together, they know this is a signature of strong storm rotation within a mesocyclone. If, within this couplet, you get a “gate to gate” (i.e. adjacent pixels) where the difference between inbound and outbound velocities exceed 90 knots, this is referred to as a “tornado vortex signature”. In this image, if you do the math, you get that the max difference between inbound and outbound velocities was 86 knots, and you an see what appears to be a tornado vortex signature.
We’ll see what the NWS’ assessment says later today, but it appears to me that there was a tornado at some point over northern Queens last night!
UPDATE (1:46PM August 3, 2018): The National Weather Service issued a report confirming that an EF0 tornado touched down in portions of College Point, Queens last night.
Thunderstorms roll through later this afternoon and into the overnight hours. The cold front bringing these storms stalls out before finally pushing through Sunday. A welcome break from this muggy weather follows, with dew points finally dropping out of the upper-60s into more comfortable ranges. The break is short lived, as the cold front will return mid-week next week as a warm front, bringing another round of warm and humid weather with chances for rain.
Rest of today – hot and humid today with high temperatures approaching 90°F and plenty of moisture still lingering. Late in the day, clouds will increase as a cold front approaches from the west. Thunderstorms are expected to develop along a pre-frontal trough. Atmospheric dynamics favor some possibility for storms to develop damaging wind gusts. There will be modest instability with little convective inhibition by later in the day with plenty of solar heating and humidity in place. Wind shear, though weak in the lower layers of the atmosphere, increases substantially aloft, and so storms do have a chance to become strong. Any storm could bring about heavy rain and isolated minor flash flooding. The best timing of the onset of the rain appears to be between 7-9PM as of recent High Resolution Rapid Refresh model runs. The Storm Prediction Center has placed the western part of the region (including parts of NYC) under a slight risk of severe weather. By the time the storms hit the city, given the current timing, they should be weakening due to day time heating ceasing.
Saturday – only slightly cooler with high temperatures in the mid-80s. Still quite muggy. Spot showers are possible due to the cold front lingering in the area.
Sunday – finally, we get a refreshing day off from the humidity with dew points dropping into the low-60s and high temperatures in the mid-80s with lots of sun. The cold front finally pushes through with high pressure behind it bringing cooler, drier Canadian air our way.
Monday – should be another comfortable day with high temperatures in the mid-80s and relatively less humid conditions.
After two days of record-breaking heat in the low-90s, a pattern change is on tap for the NYC metro area going into the weekend. Cooler conditions will prevail in the wake of the passage of a cold front, which could also bring rain and thunderstorms (possibly severe). Saturday should shape up nicely but rain chances return Sunday before a cooler start to the work week.
Rest of today – the Storm Prediction Center has placed portions of the region under a marginal-slight risk of severe thunderstorm activity today. We continue to be an increasingly moist warm sector east of an advancing low pressure center. As the cold front associated with this low pushes east, storms will initiate first along a pre-frontal trough during the day today (late morning-early afternoon), then again along the actual frontal boundary itself later this evening. It is the latter round of these storms that could push severe limits. There are limiting factors to this activity especially near the coast with more stable air present. Cloud cover will limit day time heating, reducing overall instability. And the earlier round of activity should serve to actually mitigate the later round of storms. Aside from the rain, it should be mostly cloudy with some breaks in the sun (that would increase chances for storms), with high temperatures in the mid-80s.
Saturday – cooler air moves in behind the cold front tonight while a weak area of high pressure builds. High temperatures should top out in the mid-70s with partly sunny conditions. Rain chances increase towards the overnight hours.
Sunday – cooler still with mostly cloudy skies and chances for rain. High temperatures only in the mid-60s as a weak disturbance passes to our south.
Monday – skies finally clear up with high temperatures moderating and warming into the upper-60s.
The weather on Sunday turned out to be a real gift for fathers in the region, yielding a lot more clear skies than anticipated going into the weekend. We could have a rough start this week with possible severe weather, and another chance of rain mid-week. A tropical system forming over the Gulf of Mexico bears watching this coming weekend.
Rest of today – humid and warm with high temperatures in the low to mid-80s. Mostly sunny to start. All the ingredients for possibly severe thunderstorms will be in place this afternoon and evening. A flash flood watch is in effect for most of the area west of Long Island. The Storm Prediction Center has placed some of the region west of the Hudson River under an enhanced risk of experiencing severe weather with the city itself in a slight risk area.
A vigorous cold front will move east towards NYC today. As we can feel, the airmass ahead of the front is saturated and warm. The more sun we get before the front approaches, the greater the destabilization in the atmosphere. The cold front will line up with the flow of the jet stream, which will favor line segments and training of storm cells repeatedly hitting the same areas (flash flood warning is in place because of this).
Timing of the leading edge of the storms appears to be around 5pm. Any storms or substantial cloud cover ahead of this would decrease the severe potential. Primary threat along this leading line of storms would be damaging wind gusts with a small chance for hail and a couple isolated tornadoes.
Behind this leading line of storms, we could see a slight break around 8PM, but then more rounds of moderate to heavy rains that could lead to flash flooding.
Tuesday – severe weather and rain should dissipate fairly quickly after midnight. Decreasing clouds in the wake of the cold front though high temperatures remain similar to today due to the influence of southwest winds.
Wednesday – mostly sunny with high temperatures in the low-80s. A chance for rain in the afternoon, but much milder and less widespread than today.
Thursday – mostly sunny again, with highs in the low-80s again.
Potential Tropical Storm in the Gulf
Two possible tropical systems are churning, one east of the Windward Islands and the other crossing over the Yucatan into the Gulf of Mexico. The latter system may have a tangible impact in terms of bringing tropical moisture to the area this coming weekend.
We’ve been able to enjoy a very comfortable week of summer weather. High temperatures have been largely held in check in the low-mid 80s this week. This weekend, there will be a chance for some rain Saturday, but Sunday will be another nice day with mostly sunny skies and high temperatures in the mid-80s.
Rest of today – mostly sunny, high around 85ºF.
Saturday – watching for the risk of scattered strong to severe thunderstorms tomorrow. The degree of severity will hinge upon how much cloud cover there is during the first half of the day, and whether any storms pop up early. If there are more clouds early, and some storms show up early, the available energy for storms in the afternoon associated with a cold front will be limited. Ahead of this cold front, warm, humid air will flow in, and temperatures should peak near 90ºF.
Sunday – skies will clear quickly following the passage of the aforementioned cold front. High pressure begins to take over and will give us a nice, sunny day, with highs in the mid-80s.
Monday – almost a clone of Sunday with mostly sunny skies and highs in the mid-80s.
Tuesday – with high pressure still almost directly overhead, we will get another nice day with highs in the mid-80s.
Slight Improvement in Drought Conditions
With recent rounds of heavy rain and thunderstorms that have impacted the area, we’ve seen a slight improvement in drought conditions, but the situation is still far from desirable.